He died while Martin Van Buren was a New York state senator. [6] They built a large house to accommodate themselves comfortably. The family owned a large farm at Kona, on the north fork of the Kentucky River. Martin Van Buren Bates life began traditionally enough. Acknowledgments . His father was William Ben Bates (I believe he is Benjamin Emmett Bates who married Margaret Lucas). [2], Burial in Mound Hill Cemetery, Seville, Medina County, Ohio, USA. SEVILLE, Ohio - Seville is a tiny village that does things in a big, big way. Her father was Robert Bates. Thank you to Theresa Ellenwood for creating WikiTree profile Bates-3479 through the import of LucindaElizaBatesAncestors.ged on Mar 5, 2013. circa 1870: Giant Captain Bates, husband of 8 ft 3 ins giantess Anna Swan. Born about 1839 in Tennessee, United States. The couple donated the body of Sister to science. It was at one of the numerous battles at the Cumberland Gap that he was wounded and captured, then sent off to be imprisoned at Camp Chase in Ohio. He and his unit saw action throughout the Appalachian mountains of Virginia, Kentucky and Tennessee, distinguishing himself enough to be made a Captain. Parents. Queen Victoria herself gave them two extra-large diamond-studded gold watches as wedding presents. [8][9] He was buried beside his first wife and their son in Seville. The Guinness Book of World Records and Wikipedias List of Tallest People among list him as being 7 feet 9 inches tall and weighing around 470 pounds. He was fourth among eight children the couple had. Start a free family tree online and well do the searching for you. Steve Gilly, Bates was attending university in Virginia when the Civil War broke out. More Genealogy . The Guinness Book of World Records and other reputable sources have him listed at being 7 feet 9 inches tall and weighing 470 pounds. Martin Van Buren, (born December 5, 1782, Kinderhook, New York, U.S.died July 24, 1862, Kinderhook), eighth president of the United States (1837-41) and one of the founders of the Democratic Party. The seasons of 1878, 1879 and 1880 found us leading attractions of the W. W. Cole circus. . He was a Patriot during the American Revolution, and served as a captain in the Albany County Militia's 7th Regiment. The family tree for Martin Van Buren is still in progress. He served in the New York Senate from 1813 to 1820 and thus was a member of the Court for the Correction . This database contains family trees submitted to Ancestry by users who have indicated that their tree can be viewed by all Ancestry subscribers.These trees can change over time as users edit, remove, or otherwise modify the data in their trees. An error has occured while loading the map. IMPORTANT PRIVACY NOTICE & DISCLAIMER: YOU HAVE A RESPONSIBILITY TO USE CAUTION WHEN DISTRIBUTING PRIVATE INFORMATION. Join us July 13-16! Martin Van Buren Bates had 2 children. Van Buren was born in Kinderhook, New York on December 5, 1782. Cape Girardeau, Cape Girardeau County, MO, USA, Fredericksburg, Spotsylvania County, VA, USA, John Wallis Bates, Sarah Sally Bates (born Waldroup). Search All Records ; . We encourage you to research and examine these records to determine their accuracy. Over the intervening years, the couple endured hardships in childbearing, a son and a daughter dying shortly after birth. His wide array of involvements and accomplishments make Bates one of the most memorable veterans of the Civil War. Bates remained a captive until the wars end. The story aboveappears inourNovember / December 2020issue. Before the war, his first occupation was as a schoolteacher. And it was Ingalls who brought the Kentucky River Giant the greatest gift of his life. Whether you're looking to immerse yourself in a rich culture, hop on a tour, enjoy a little comfort food or find your bliss away from the everyday, you'll find what you are We collect and match historical records that Ancestry users have contributed to their family trees to create each person's profile. Despite his mammoth size, Bates adult life began in a normal pattern for the time. His huge size soon caught the attention of opposing Union troops, who referred to the Confederate giant as a man large enough to make five men, with the fight of 50. I had determined to become a farmer, so I stocked my farm with the best breeds of cattle, most of them being short horns. And they were apparently happy for 10 years. A man by the name of Martin van Buren Bates settled there with his wife in 1873 and put Seville, Ohio on the map, so to speak. Angelica Singleton Duer 1878-. Fourth Quarter and Bates 1 run Jacke kick. While she spent much of her adult life in Seville, Ohio, the Giantess Anna Swan Museum in Tatamagouche tells Anna's life story including her marriage to fellow giant, Martin Van Buren Bates. Every purchase supports the mission. It consisted of 130 acres [0.53km2; 53ha] of good land. MARTIN VAN BUREN BATES was of normal size at birth, was the son of normal parents and his brothers and sisters were of average height and weight. John Wallis Bates Jr. is a brother to Captain Martin Van Buren Bates. If you would like to view one of these trees in its entirety, you can contact the owner of the tree to request permission to see the tree. "My rest was not to last long, for yielding to the solicitations of managers, I consented to again travel. . Van Buren's non-British ancestry (his parents were Dutch) would break one presidential mold, and his modest upbringing was preceded only by that of Andrew Jackson. Mind Hoard 6 run t Anderson kick 4 33. He Never Admitted Texas. In growing up and receiving an education in the south, Bates ideologically aligned with Confederate politics and prepared himself to defend these values as the Civil War commenced. He grew to be over six feet tall and weighing almost 300 pounds by the time he was twelve or thirteen years old. tes), Martha Irby Craft (born Bates), Eliza Agnes Wright (born Bates), Jesse Bates, James Bates, Robert Bates, Uriah Bates, Sarah Ann Mul Boston, Suffolk County, Massachusetts, United States. He explains the next few years in his autobiography: Anna Bates died unexpectedly in her sleep at her home on August 5, 1888, just before her 42nd birthday. WIKITREE PROTECTS MOST SENSITIVE INFORMATION BUT ONLY TO THE EXTENT STATED IN THE TERMS OF SERVICE AND PRIVACY POLICY. He travelled to Cincinnati, and there joined the circus, exhibiting his enormous stature to curious onlookers. George Walker 12 Feb 1862 Van Buren, Tennessee, United States - 28 Oct 1943 managed by Janine Isleman Mary Walker 15 Dec 1820 Maury, Tennessee, United States - 11 Apr 1898 managed by Iona Harris Jack Gilbert Walker 17 Nov 1934 Mississippi, USA - 10 Apr 2013 managed by Vivian Marshall Martin Van Buren BATES married Anna Haining Swan and had 2 children. CONTENT MAY BE COPYRIGHTED BY WIKITREE COMMUNITY MEMBERS. As an aside: considerably taller than Big Dave was Martin Van Buren Bates of the CSA, whose wife from . The Giants of Seville Ohio were the l. Genealogy for Anna Haining Bates (Swan) (1848 - 1888) family tree on Geni, with over 230 million profiles of ancestors and living relatives. . . The native of Kona, Kentucky, near Whitesburg in Letcher County, became an international circus star, especially after his marriage in 1871 to a woman even taller than he was. Discover (and save!) The Bateses and their son are buried in Mound Hill Cemetery, Seville. He and Ingalls were talking about organizing a tour of Europe, to introduce Bates and his great stature to the people of that continent. Oftentimes the family trees listed as still in progress have derived from research into famous people who have a kinship to this person. These trees can change over time as users edit, remove, or otherwise modify the data in their trees. Wrong username or password. He was 28 inches [71cm] tall and weighed twenty-three pounds [10kg] and was perfect in every respect. Eventually, this command merged into the Seventh Confederate Cavalry operated by Colonel Clarene J. Prentis. SWAN, ANNA HAINING (Bates), giantess; b. In May 1874, Anna gave birth to their eighteen-pound (8.2 kg) child, but it was born stillborn. Aug 25, 2018 - Explore Owen Wright's board "Martin V. B. Bates" on Pinterest. Or was he just 74? Search for yourself and well build your family tree together, Do not sell or share my personal information. Whats not contested is that he was born on November 9 at Kona, in Letcher County, Kentucky, to John Wallis Bates and his wife, Sarah. He was severely wounded in a battle around the Cumberland Gap area and also captured, although he later escaped. He later joined the Jeffersonian Republicans, became active in local politics and government, and served as Kinderhook's town clerk . And with even stronger longevity than little brother Martin, Bob passed away in 1921, at the age of 101. Whatever their sizes, on May 19, 1872, Anna gave birth to a stillborn daughter that weighed 18 pounds and was 27 inches long. Send Students on School Field Trips to Battlefields Your Gift Tripled. He was severely wounded in a battle around the Cumberland Gap area and also captured, although he later escaped. He passed away on 7 Jan 1919 in Seville, Medina, Ohio, USA. Stay up-to-date on the American Battlefield Trust's battlefield preservation efforts, travel tips, upcoming events, history content and more. It was said that one of his boots could hold a half-bushel of shelled corn, about 28 pounds of the grain. Martin Van Buren Bates, known as the "Kentucky Giant" among other nicknames, was a Civil War-era American famed for his incredibly large size. More on the eight-year disparity in a moment, but first to what would make Bates an international circus and social-circle sensation as part of a couple who by the 1870s toured the world as The Largest Married Couple in the World.. As a young lawyer, Van Buren became involved in New York politics. John Van Buren 1810-1866 Married 22 June 1841 to Elizabeth Vanderpoel 1810-1844 with. [4]:86 He subsequently joined the 5th Kentucky Infantry Confederate States Army, later becoming a lieutenant and then captain. Though born an infant of normal size into a family of normal-sized people in Letcher County, Kentucky, he is said to at one time have been 7 feet 11 inches in height. Barnum circus. These trees can change over time as users edit, remove, or otherwise modify the data in their trees. Four different courses from the disciplines of Psychology, (Photo by Hulton Archive/Getty Images). Sign up to receive the latest information on the American Battlefield Trust's efforts to blaze The Liberty Trail in South Carolina. Historical Person Search Search Search Results Results Martin Van Buren Bates (1908 - 1930) Try FREE for 14 days Try FREE for 14 days How do we create a person's profile? His father, Abraham van Buren (1737-1817) was a farmer, the owner of a few slaves, and a tavern-keeper in Kinderhook. [4]:87 Martin described the next few years in his autobiography: While in Ohio, I purchased a farm in Seville, Medina County. Stay up-to-date on our FREE educational resources & professional development opportunities, all designed to support your work teaching American history. Van Buren (141) Haralson (143) Ogle (141) St. Joseph (141) O'Brien (141) Osborne (141) Logan (141) . If you would like to view one of these trees in its entirety, you can contact the owner of the tree to request permission to see the tree. . Martin Van Buren Bates (November 9, 1837 - January 19, 1919), known as the "Kentucky Giant" was an American man famed for his great height. His family was poor, he had little education, and he lived on what was then the western part of , got your result about martin van buren family tree please comment if we missed anything here, please let us know. He is my 3rd Great-Grand Uncle -Captain Martin Van Buren Bates (Born in Letcher County, KY -Died in Seville, OH)- Confederate Gathered from those who lived during the same time period , were born in the same place, or who have a family name in common. Anna Swan, from Nova Scotia, Canada, was an accomplished performer before she met her would-be husband. Martin Van Buren. Research genealogy for Martin Van Buren Bates of Whitesburg, Letcher County, Kentucky, United States of America, as well as other members of the Bates family, on Ancestry. Thank you to Theresa Ellenwood for creating WikiTree profile Bates-3479 through the import of LucindaElizaBatesAncestors.ged on Mar 5, 2013. You can contact the owner of the tree to get more information. I built a house upon it designed especially for our comfort. Martin Van Buren Bates (November 9, 1837 January 19, 1919), known as the Kentucky Giant, was an American man famed for his great height. Even as a state senator, US senator, ambassador, vice president and later president, Martin Van Buren would essentially run New York State politics. Martin Van Buren BATES family tree Family tree Explore more family trees. It consisted of 130 acres of good land. . In 1776, she married Abraham van Buren. The seasons of 1878, 1879 and 1880 found us leading attractions of the W.W. Cole circus. The tour with Anna was a triumph. 9 Nov 1837 - Whitesburg, Letcher County, Kentucky, USA. We present interim results from a large study that tracks undergraduate students' interaction with a variety of online media designed to enhance learning in an on-campus environment. [1], Martin remarried Anna Laron (Annette LaVonne) Weatherby in 1890. Martin was listed in the 1850 Census. Capt. See more ideas about bates, van buren, martin. tes, Margaret Johnson (born Bates), Martha Irby Bates, Henry Bates, Eliza Agnes Wright (born Bates), Jesse Bates, James Bates, Robin Bate Whitesburg, Letcher County, Kentucky, United States of America, District, Letcher, Kentucky, United States, Seville, Medina County, OH, United States, Seville, Medina County, Ohio, United States, Seville, Medina County, Ohio, United States of America, Caudell-Caudill-Frost-Bowker-Snell Family Web Site, Martin Van Buren Kentucky Giant and Babe Bates. The passage above was reprinted together with a precise citation pointing to The Angry Christian. Martin van Buren was born on December 30 1812, to Martin van Buren and Hannah van Buren. John Wallis Bates 1779 - 1843. Martin and his wife returned to Ohio in 1872 and settled down in Seville. 1845. After receiving several promotions in this regiment in response to his bravery and leadership, Bates became First Lieutenant of the Virginia State Line Troops Company A in 1863 where he developed his skills under Colonel John B. Floyds guidance. The highly publicized wedding, at St. Martin-in-the-Fields in London, England, drew thousands of people trying to attend, due to both the uncommonness of the spectacle and the couple's disarming good nature. Martin Van Buren Bates was born in 1837 in Eastern Kentucky and lived a long life dying in 1919. Martin passed away on March 19 1855, at age 42. Martin van Buren was the eighth president of the United States. 7, No. Mno Hoard 16 pass Horn Cunningham t Anderson kit a. He was apparently of unremarkable size at birth. 532, Subpt. Their graves are marked simply "Babe" and "Sister." (FOOTNOTE Capt. He was born in a little town called Kinderhook, New . We collect and match historical records that Ancestry users have contributed to their family trees to create each person's profile. excluding sugar cane, such as tree fruits, tree nuts, grapes, olives, native pasture and perennial forage. The wedding, at St. Martin-in-the-Fields in London, was abuzz with publicity, and thousands of people, drawn both by the uncommonness of the spectacle and the disarming good nature of the pair, tried to attend. The two fell in love, and before the end of the year, Miss Swan would become Mrs. Bates. Martin Van Buren BATES married Anna Haining Swan and had 2 children. time to thr draft hoard heads, whose guest he will be. His father is Jesse Bates (brother to Martin Van Buren Bates). She never got over the loss of her second husband in 1817 and died less than a year after him. She and Martin worked in the circus as the tallest married couple. Besides being the home of two literal giants, Capt. Captain Martin Van Buren Bates, formerly of the Confederate Army, was grieving. President Andrew Jackson, a southerner, favored the annexation of Texas. by On 19 May 1872, Anna gave birth to a daughter, who weighed 18lb (8.2kg) and died at birth. [10] He is currently the tallest known person to live to be at least 80 years old. People . My cemetery family travel to Seville, Ohio Mound Hill Cemetery to find the final resting place of two married giants! Jan 8, 2017 - This Pin was discovered by Wade Johnson. Martin Van Buren, born on December 5, 1782, was the first American President not born a British subject. This database contains family trees submitted to Ancestry by users who have indicated that their tree can only be viewed by Ancestry members to whom they have granted permission to see their tree. By the time he was 13 he weighed 300 pounds and was as tall as a man. Van Buren 72956 Abilities Unlimited of Hot springs, Arkansas Inc. 530 Mountain Pine Road . In 1889 he remarried, this time to a woman of normal stature, Annette LaVonne Weatherby,[7] and lived a mostly peaceful life until his death in 1919 of nephritis. This history of the life of Martin Van Buren Bates is adapted with permission from the podcast Stories, A History of Appalachia, produced by Steve Gilly and Rod Mullins. While the circus was on tour in Halifax, Canada, the 7-foot-11-inch tall Anna Haining Swan visited. It is just one of scores of fascinating stories from the southern Appalachiansall told in relaxed, conversational style by Steve and Rod. Born in Whitesburg, Letcher County, Kentucky, United States of America on 9 November 1837 to John Wallis Bates and Sarah Walthrop. 2 - Winter 1996 First National Bank P.O. Soon it was impossible to deny that he was going to be bigger than his big brothers and sisters, not to mention his parents. On November 9, 1837, in Letcher County, Kentucky, Martin Van Buren Bates was born to parents of normal stature. Abraham Van Buren supported the American Revolution and later the Jeffersonian Republicans. CFR Title 5. }); The Kentucky River Giant: Martin Van Buren Bates Claimed 7' 11", Martin Van Buren Bates: 7 11; 525 lbs. He was Surrogate of Columbia County between 1808 and 1813. Discover the meaning and history behind your last name and get a sense of identity and discover who you are and where you come from. Although Bates was rumored to be seven feet eleven inches, official documentation lists Bates as seven foot nine and approximately 500 pounds. Sarah Gracie Duer 1876-1950. hbspt.forms.create({ After college, Bates worked as a school teacher. Barnums curiosities in July of 1865, and he traveled with the circus all over the United States and Canada for five years. Letcher County native Martin Van Buren Bates and his wife, Anna, were known as the "Love Giants" after they married in 1871. Husband of Annette LaVonne Bates and Anna Haining Bates Click Here. At the Civil Wars onset, Bates enlisted as a private in the Fifth Kentucky Infantry on September 15th, 1861. Martin Bates served in the United States Civil War. Upon the outbreak of the . Martin's most significant sibling was James Van Allen. He was born in Kentucky to the Bates family who were all of average human height. Finding his immense proportions as an object of wonder, Bates enrolled himself as one of P.T. Brother of Elizabeth Ashurst; John Wallis Bates, Jr.; Mary Jane Bates; Henry Bates; Margaret Johnson and 10 others; Martha Craft; Elizabeth Agnes Wright; Jesse Waltrip Bates; James Bates; Robert Robin Bates, Sr.; Uriah Bates; Sarah Ann Mullins; Henderson Robert Bates; Mary Jane Bates and William J. Bates less His father, Abraham van Buren (17371817) was a farmer, the owner of a few slaves, and a tavern-keeper in Kinderhook. Date of Birth - Death November 9, 1837 - January 19, 1919. The Batess and their son are buried in Mound Hill Cemetery in Seville, Ohio. B, App. More astonishingly, Bates continued to grow until the age of 28. If so, login to add it. We collect and match historical records that Ancestry users have contributed to their family trees to create each persons profile. Children . However, persisting violence between former Union and Confederate troops prompted Bates northern migration to Cincinnati, Ohio. Bates' growth rate jumped at the age of six or seven. [4]:87. Martin Van Buren Bates (1837-1919) on Find A Grave: Memorial #6194083 retrieved 10 March 2018 Wikipedia contributors, . Sign up for our quarterly email series highlighting the environmental benefits of battlefield preservation. This time to Lavonne Weatherby, the daughter of the pastor of the Seville Baptist Church. Here are some entries from Martin Van Buren Bates journal referring to his time with Anna on the tour: By 1872 they were using the billing of The Largest Married Couple in the World. He was apparently of unremarkable size at birth. Whitesburg, Letcher, Kentucky, United States, Marriage of Captain Martin van Buren to Anna Swan, https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:M65D-K3T, https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:M65D-K3T, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Martin_Van_Buren_Bates&oldid=702792697, https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:7QCR-TLZM, https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:2DLW-VDC, https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/6194083/martin-van_buren-bates, 5th Regiment, Kentucky Infantry (Confederate), United States Civil War, "United States Census, 1850," database with images, FamilySearch (. martin van buren, viiith president of the united states: born dec. 5, 1782, died july 24, 1862. hannah van buren. Donations to the Trust are tax deductible to the full extent allowable under the law. MAINLINE HEALTH SYSTEMS INC. 233 North Main Street Portland AR 71663. Martin Van Buren Bates' life began traditionally enough. . The Martin Van Buren Papers, one of twenty-three presidential collections in the Library of Congress Manuscript Division, contains more than 6,000 items dating from 1787 to circa 1910. Youll get hints when we find information about your relatives . Martin County Residential Services, Inc. 6003 W Main Street Ext Williamston 27892 MARVA Workshop, Inc. This database contains family trees submitted to Ancestry by users who have indicated that their tree can be viewed by all Ancestry subscribers. Discover the meaning and history behind your last name and get a sense of identity and discover who you are and where you come from. formId: "520dca37-e1cd-4cc8-bff2-42ffb2fdf82e" Box 4699 Oneida, TN . Thank you for visiting martin van buren family tree page. Martin (159) Van Buren (159) Todd (153) Winston (159) Pettis (159) Seward (159) Rowan (159) . Unsourced family tree handed down to Jack Adams. Martin Van Buren's mother was Maria Hoes (van Alen) van Buren (17471818). Martin and his wife returned to Ohio in 1872 and settled down in Seville. Yet MARTIN BATES grew into a man seven feet and eleven inches tall . On December 5, 1782, they gave birth to Martin Van Buren in Kinderhook, New York. Bates endured his first growth spurt around the age of seven and measured in at six feet and 200 pounds by the age of twelve. Discover your family history in millions of family trees and more than a billion birth,marriage, death, census, and miltary records. Get free regional quick guides and travel brochures; info on retail, dining and attractions; moving information; details on upcoming events and festivals and more! This FREE annual event brings together educators from all over the world for sessions, lectures, and tours from leading experts. The statement by Ghezzi was remembered in the 1991 book Secrets of Your Family Tree: Healing for Adult Children of Dysfunctional Families. 7 Aug. 1846 at Mill Brook, N.S., one of 13 children of Alexander Swan and Ann Graham; m. 17 June 1871 Martin Van Buren Bates, known as the "Kentucky giant"; d. 5 Aug. 1888 at Seville, Ohio. [5], He returned to Kentucky after the war. Owing to problems with obtaining a casket large enough for Anna, Martin soon had his own casket specially built and stored it in his barn until it was needed. This database contains family trees submitted to Ancestry by users who have indicated that their tree can be viewed by all Ancestry subscribers.These trees can change over time as users edit, remove, or otherwise modify the data in their trees. He traveled across the Kentucky line to Washington County, Virginia, to attend Emory & Henry College, then becoming a schoolteacher. This incredible growth reportedly so astonished his parents that they forbade him from doing chores around the house, fearing that his body would be too fragile. She and Martin soon got to know each other, and were married during an 1871 tour of the circus in Europe. Son of John Wallis Bates, Sr. and Sarah Bates The furniture was all built to order and to see our guests make use of it recalls most forcibly the good Dean Swift's traveler in the land of Brobdingnag. is Bates, Margaret (Peggy) Johnson (born Bates), Henry Bates, Martha Irby Bates, Eliza Agnes Bates, Jesse Bates, Captain James Bates, Rob Nov 9 1837 - Whitesburg, Letcher, Kentucky, United States, Jan 19 1919 - Seville, Medina, Ohio, United States, Anna Swan, Lavonne Weatherby, Anna Haining Bates. They moved to Ohio in 1872, settling in Seville. Bates spent his final days on a vast farm, and he passed away at the age of 82 on January 19, 1919. Martin is 14 degrees from Jennifer Aniston, 20 degrees from Drew Barrymore, 17 degrees from Candice Bergen, 23 degrees from Alexandre Dumas, 14 degrees from Carrie Fisher, 30 degrees from Whitney Houston, 19 degrees from Hayley Mills, 17 degrees from Liza Minnelli, 10 degrees from Lisa Presley, 18 degrees from Kiefer Sutherland, 16 degrees from Bill Veeck and 21 degrees from Brian Nash on our single family tree. Annette Castle - 09/03/97 02:59:18 My Email:11071,1462@compuserve.com Where are . The two fell in love, and after accepting an offer from the Judge of Ingalls to make a tour throughout Europe, they planned to marry. Its been said that even Queen Victoria herself gave them two extra-large diamond-studded gold watches as wedding presents no doubt to accommodate their extra-large wrists. My rest was not to last long, for the solicitations of managers, I consented to again travel. Martin ordered a statue of her from Europe for her grave, sold the oversized house, and moved into the town. C. Read the code on FindLaw Thank you for your support! The bulk of the material dates from the 1820s, when Van Buren (1782-1862) was a U.S. senator from New York, through his service as secretary of state and vice president in the Andrew Jackson administrations . He joined the John Robinson Circus and its Cabinet of Curiositiesthe sideshow or freak show. Along with Bates came his cousin, John Wright, who joined the same circus as a marksman who performed his shootist show on the back of a galloping horse while aiming at targets with his pistol. To relieve their grief they took a trip to Europe again, this time not as part of the circus. In the real sense of the word, he was a perfectly formed giant. Just one grandparent can lead you to many Finally, Bates accepted Ingalls European tour plan, and in 1871 Bates traveled to Elizabeth, New Jersey to finalize the plan.